• Sophie Likes Cake
  • Ask Me Anything
  • Blog
  • Cakes & Sweet Treats
  • Ice Cream
  • Savoury & Meals
Menu

Sophie Likes Cake

Ok so sometimes I make a little more than just cake but I love creating and sharing it with you here
  • Sophie Likes Cake
  • Ask Me Anything
  • Blog
  • Cakes & Sweet Treats
  • Ice Cream
  • Savoury & Meals

Butter Baking's Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

August 20, 2013

You could seriously survive for months with the amount of food stuck in the nooks and crannies of my iPhone.

Its disgusting really. Cookie dough, cake batter and I even found some curry from the other night.

And to think I put this in my mouth when my hands are full. Someone should do a study on the relationship between amount of iPhone dirt and incidence of illness in the population. Because I have to say I think I got one tiny wee cold this year and that has been it.

Why do I have so much food in/on my phone?

Because I am too poor/retarded for a proper camera to take photos of so my phone is always in the kitchen. Often my hands are covered in cookie dough when I go to take photos of a stage or process.

And as we all know cooking/baking doesn't count unless you Instagram it right :P

On that note, apologies for the dull/yellow photos. My flatmate was watching tv and had all the lights off hence why it looks like I live in a cave . . .

There aren't that many cookies you can make. They are all sort of variations of a specific type. You can have oat based, vanilla based, ground nut based or chocolate based. In the back of my mind I have been on the hunt for the ultimate chocolate chip cookie. One that is crisp at the edges, rustic to look at and most importantly chewy and gooey on the inside.

My usual recipe just doesn't quite cut the mustard. They are great when they come straight out of the oven but the next day I find them to be a wee bit hard. They still get eaten but the satisfaction and delight just isn't there.

But, there is this glorious blog. . . .

If you love cookies, chocolate, peanut butter and most importantly Nutella then you should probably go and look at it right now.

butterbaking.com

I am not even going to attempt to describe its wonder. There are no words.

Apparently the New York Times recipe is the best recipe she has ever made. The only problem is that you have to let it chill for 36 hours. I don't know about you but when I want cookies I usually want them now! So I shall prepare the dough for that now just in time for my next cookie attack. In the meantime I shall share my adventure here.

It is a pretty typical chocolate chip cookies recipe. I would say the main difference is in how you shape the balls to bake.

I really dislike fork marks on cookies. It really grinds my gears. I have been searching for a way to get around this for yonks and I think this is the answer I have been looking for.

After you chill the dough for half an hour, roll it into balls (the size of which is up to you really). Then you take the ball and tear it in half. You then turn each half 90 degrees so the jagged internal surfaces are facing upward. You then awkwardly join the two pieces together like that at the base being careful not to flatten the jagged top edges. When you pop them on the tray they kind of look like dumplings.

There are pretty pictures describing it

here

.

These could have been made better if I splurged out and bought the larger Cadbury chocolate drops. But I am too poor and they were almost double the price for half as much. There is a serious gap in the market here . . .

Roughly chopped chocolate chunks would have been a dream in these too. I am thinking the Whittaker's creamy milk would be an absolute dream. Yes?

So without further adieu, lets get down to business.

Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies

As made by

Butter Baking

, original recipe from

Baking Illustrated

Makes around 30 medium sized cookies

165g butter, melted but cooled until warm

1 cup packed brown sugar

1/2 cup white sugar

1 egg

1 egg yolk

1 teaspoon vanilla

2 cups and 2 Tablespoons plain flour

1/2 teaspoon baking powder

1/2 teaspoon salt

1 cup chocolate chips or chunks or whatever

In a standing mixer or with an electric beater, beat together the butter and sugars until a thick and smooth mixture develops. Mix in the egg then the yolk and vanilla until thick and smooth.

Add in the flour and baking soda and mix until just combined. Then stir in the chocolate chips.

Chill the mixture in the fridge for half an hour before rolling out.

Preheat the oven to 170C on bake and line a baking tray with baking paper.

Take heaped tablespoonfuls of dough and roll it into a ball. Then tear this ball in half, turn the halves 90 degrees so the jagged edges face upwards then join the halves together at the sides to form a 'pinched' dumpling looking thing.

Leaving about 5cm between each ball, place the balls on the tray and bake for 12 minutes or until they only just start turning golden (they will continue to bake themselves even when they are out of the oven). Once cool and firm enough to move, transfer to a wire cooling rack or clean tea towel. Bake the rest.

Enjoy with a nice glass of milk! They are even fantastic the next day (if they last that long!)

In "Baking Illustrated", "Butter Baking", "Chocolate Chip Cookies", "Chocolate Chip", "Cookies", "Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies"
← Baby HummingbirdsTim Tam Chocolate Tarts →

What do you feel like?


Want it straight from the oven? Subscribe here.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


On my bench now: latest and greatest

Sophie Likes Cake
Bubble Friendly Eclairs (Chocolate Eclairs with Custard)
Bubble Friendly Eclairs (Chocolate Eclairs with Custard)
about 3 years ago
Lockdown Chutney: Feijoa and Date
about 4 years ago
Sweet Lemon and Thyme Marmalade
Sweet Lemon and Thyme Marmalade
about 4 years ago
Brown Butter Pear Cake with Caramel Cream Cheese Icing
Brown Butter Pear Cake with Caramel Cream Cheese Icing
about 5 years ago
Strawberry and Rhubarb Filled Cakelets With Not Too Sweet Mascarpone
Strawberry and Rhubarb Filled Cakelets With Not Too Sweet Mascarpone
about 5 years ago

Fresh off the feed: 

Instagram

Recipe number 40 is rather special. A week ago today Nana left this earth. To celebrate her life we all gathered in Matamata and of course there was afternoon tea. The Aunties and I all made something of hers. I was on cheesecakes. Welsh cheesecakes
Dylan and I made this @katherine_sabbath stunner yesterday to celebrate Chris’ birthday. Needless to say it went down an absolute treat 🍳🌽🍡
Apologies for the crap photos but I’d like to share the recipe for this family favourite. I’ve written about Dad’s favourite veggie casserole over on TheSupperClubKitchen.com under recipes worth sharing. It’s 90s nostalgia at
We’ve always seen making our own croissants as a pretty daunting task. I feel like there is a lot of mystique around their making that only trained experts can get their heads around. Since we had little else to do we (Dylan) decided to give ma
Proud as punch for actually completing 
@bonappetitmag’s best ever bread recipe. It only took us three days but we’re here. Having this tonight with Ima’s chicken soup. Just call me Henny Penny.
Dylan put some words together about the long lunch we cooked ourselves last weekend. You can find it over on thesupperclubkitchen.com

Twitter

  • Sophie Edmonds
    Thai Inspired Slaw Salad https://t.co/5hcHE04G4F
    Nov 16, 2015, 12:05 AM
  • Sophie Edmonds
    Praise @CriticTeArohi for finally raising all that is scary about #fitspo!
    Apr 8, 2015, 3:36 AM
  • Sophie Edmonds
    RT @JamieLowryMe: Hi @Sophie_edo! I made your banoffee cupcakes today!! Still working on my icing but they taste incredible! #thankyou http://t.co/qIg3w4tbfu
    Mar 20, 2015, 6:49 AM

Powered by Squarespace